Image credit: Em Stonham for Kyusai/Gameloft
Disney Dreamlight Valley: The Keepsake Sea is a charming addition to the already beloved cozy game staple, letting players dip below the waves and become merfolk. Despite being someone who’s played DDV on and off for a few years, it’s the first expansion I’ve played from start to finish.
While I had a good time playing through The Keepsake Sea, it wasn’t all smooth sailing – and you can be shore I’ll sneak in some more sea puns as the article continues. Here’s a full review of Disney Dreamlight Valley: The Keepsake Sea, completed on PC and Steam Deck, with story spoilers.
I sea what you did there

Disney Dreamlight Valley is a household name in the cozy gaming scene, and it has one shell of a dedicated fanbase. It’s got all the typical trappings of the genre; cute villagers, farming and home decoration mechanics, and low-stakes, slightly grindy gameplay.
The Keepsake Sea is the game’s fourth foray into the world of expansion packs, kickstarting with a mysterious letter from a friend, beckoning the player below the ocean surface. It’s presented as a mystery, anyway – the letter is signed as “W” and Wendy from Peter Pan is on the splash art.
The player quickly develops a mermaid tail, courtesy of a magical gemstone from sea witch and unbelievable icon Ursula, letting them dive underwater and access new realms via whirlpools. This opens up new ways of fishing, a speedy method of travel, and, most importantly, a whole new area of the map.
There are three major sections of the map in The Keepsake Sea; Shipwreck Shores, Candy Cove, and the Kingdom of Oublié. Shipwreck Shore is a cluster of pirate-themed desert islands, Candy Cove is a sprinkling of pastel-themed dessert islands, and the Kingdom of Oublié is a magical palatial area, complete with a throne room and long-lost lagoon.

The story unfolds in a linear fashion, with the player being taken from region to region as they complete Guardian Trials.
These Trials involve completing a set number of Duties – if you’re unfamiliar, Duties are like daily quests in World of Warcraft; essentially, small challenges or repetitive tasks. They’re presented as riddles, though. One Duty might be to “spend time with an untrustworthy captain” which means to hang out with Captain Jack Sparrow.
The Guardians are large stone statues of mermaids that can, for some reason, talk. As the story unfolds, it becomes clear that the Guardians were put in place to protect something important to the player character, with the grand reveal happening in the eye of a spectacular storm. It’s a neat story, and I enjoyed the dialogue options given to the player in each Guardian interaction.
There’s a type of sub-quest associated with the Guardians called Sunken Echos. These are simple puzzle-like sections where you need to interact with objects to complete a scene. Visually, they’re cute – they’re styled as if you’re reliving a memory to solve a puzzle – but I found the actual process to be quite boring. For the most part, they can be brute forced in under a minute.
Telling tails of pirates

One of my favorite things about The Keepsake Sea is that it let me live out my eight year old self’s fantasy of being a mermaid-pirate. That may sound sarcastic, but I mean it with all of my heart – nostalgic joy radiates off of this expansion, tapping directly into the whimsical play-pretend scenarios that I got lost in as a kid.
Let me expand on mermaid-pirates, though. Not only do you get to transform into a merperson and customize your tail, fins, and ears, you also get given a magical pirate ship that can teleport from dock to dock. This ship can salvage treasure while you’re sailing, and comes equipped with cooking and crafting stations. It’s exceptionally convenient.
Pirates make up a big part of the featured characters, too. Captain Jack Sparrow and Captain Hook both play a big part in the expansion story, alongside Wendy, Megara, Dory, Milo, and Ursula. It’s a weird cast, but an endearing one.
The visuals in The Keepsake Sea stood out to me, too, specifically thanks to the variety in styles across the different biomes. Shipwreck Shores was jewel-toned and sunny, Candy Cove was saccharine sweet, complete with candy-coated penguins to befriend – called Meringuins, if you’re interested – and the Kingdom of Oublié was deeply elegant.

Unfortunately, the visual performance didn’t always hold up for me during my playthrough of The Keepsake Sea. Characters would sometimes float a meter above the ground or entirely off the side of the ship while sailing, there were odd clipping textures, and shadows would pop in at random during certain points of the game.
Characters also had a tendency to appear from nowhere during the middle of cutscenes, or walk in front of the player’s vision, obscuring important details. Megara drove her submarine (everyone gets a submarine in the underwater sections, just so you know) directly in front of me during a Sunken Echoes puzzle while the camera was fixed, and I couldn’t see what I was doing.
I did also find that the gameplay got a little repetitive in certain places. Disney Dreamlight Valley has always had grindy gameplay and it’s never bothered me too much – I find it meditative – but this expansion teetered into eye-rolling territory, namely due to the Sunken Echoes puzzles.
Perhaps it’s due to me binging the expansion over the course of a couple of days, but I ended up dreading when a Sunken Echo puzzle would pop up. These segments got old quickly, and I ended up zoning out listening to a podcast whenever I had to do them.
It is worth noting that I played through the expansion on a mid-range PC and Steam Deck; in the former’s case, the specs are not exceptional, so take my quibbles about performance with a pinch of sea salt.
Ultimately, I had a good time with The Keepsake Sea, largely due to the vibrantly nostalgic experience of playing pirate-mermaids with recognizable characters. I’m not necessarily a Disney fan – I can see Disney geeks loving this expansion more than I did – but I still enjoyed my time playing, and would recommend checking it out.
FAQs
Disney Dreamlight Valley came out in full on December 5, 2023.
There are four main Disney Dreamlight Valley expansions including The Keepsake Sea.
Yes, as per the official Steam page and my own testing, DDV works great on Steam Deck. It just may get a little toasty during long play sessions.
DDV: The Keepsake Sea is worth it, despite a few quirks and hiccups. It’s a fun and colorful expansion with lots of content.
